Found a PCB failure? Now what?

A short, an open, or a solder joint that looks wrong is the beginning of a process rather than a conclusion. What follows is the sequence for identifying, verifying, and correcting a board failure without guessing at any step.

Step 1: Confirm the failure mode

Start by establishing whether the failure is electrical, mechanical, or thermal in origin.

An electrical test tells you something is wrong. It does not tell you why, and the difference matters because the corrective action depends entirely on the cause. A cold joint under a BGA, a void on a QFN thermal pad, a short circuit, a missing solder connection, a head-in-pillow defect, and a solder void can present similarly at the test bench while requiring completely different responses.

Understanding the structure of the assembly is what makes the rest of the process work. Imaging shows what is physically there, and interpreting that image depends on knowing what should be there.

Step 2: Classify the defect and identify its cause

Once a defect is located, classify it, because each class points back at a different part of the process.

Shorts commonly result from excess solder volume, solder mask design, or a process issue during assembly. Opens frequently trace to component misalignment or coplanarity problems, where a lead or ball never made proper contact in the first place.

Head-in-pillow is worth understanding specifically. It occurs when the solder ball on a BGA and the paste beneath it fail to coalesce during reflow, usually because of oxidation on one or both surfaces. The two make contact without merging, which is where the name comes from. The joint may pass a continuity test while remaining mechanically fragile, and it is essentially invisible without X-ray.

Step 3: Decide whether the board is worth reworking

Not every board should be repaired, and this decision belongs before the rework rather than after it.

Ask whether the component is genuinely replaceable, whether the repair will affect performance or long-term reliability, and how the cost of rework compares to the cost of scrapping the assembly.

High-value assemblies often justify rework on cost alone. Damage that extends deep into a multilayer structure usually argues the other way, because internal damage to inner layers or vias cannot be corrected from the surface, and a board repaired around underlying damage becomes a field failure later.

Step 4: Rework correctly

If the decision is to repair, the rework itself introduces new risk that has to be managed.

Use appropriate thermal profiles during reflow, since the assembly has already been through at least one full thermal cycle and additional heat carries its own consequences for surrounding components. Replace oxidized or damaged parts rather than reusing them, particularly when oxidation contributed to the original defect.

Step 5: Validate the repair

Do not assume the rework worked. Verify it.

X-ray inspection of the rework zone confirms mechanical integrity and reveals problems that reworking can introduce. Tilted 2.5D views and computed tomography expose conditions such as lifted balls and internal delamination that no surface inspection or electrical test will catch.

Follow that with functional and thermal testing to confirm electrical reliability under operating conditions. In aerospace, medical device, defense, and automotive applications this validation step is not optional, since a repaired assembly entering service unverified carries the same risk profile as the original defect.

Step 6: Ask why it happened

The last step is the one that pays for the process.

Many failures trace back to a small number of causes: incorrect solder paste volume, poor thermal profiling, oxidized components, or improper board handling. Each of those is a process condition rather than a random event, which means finding it prevents the next occurrence rather than only fixing this one.

This is where X-ray earns its place beyond diagnosis. It closes the feedback loop between what failed and what produced the failure, which turns each individual defect into information about the process that made it.

Every failure carries a lesson if the tools exist to read it. With a defined process and the ability to see inside the assembly, the work stops being board repair and becomes reliability engineering.

Creative Electron X-Ray Systems

Explore Industrial X-Ray Inspection & CT Systems

Compare Creative Electron X-ray inspection systems for PCB and SMT inspection, medical devices, industrial quality control, 2D X-ray, planar CT, 3D CT, automated inspection, AI analysis, and X-ray component counting.

Want to learn more?

Contact the X-ray People!

Contact Us
Intended Use

All information is confidential.

X-Ray University

Learn more from The X-Ray People!

Search our knowledge base or browse topics from the engineers and X-ray experts at Creative Electron.

Search X-Ray University